4.01 ''The Same Deep Water As You''

[Bethany Joy]

Sorry everyone! This thread got deleted somehow, so why don't we start it again

What did you all think of the Premiere of the 4th season of OTH? I thought that it was really amazing. I am really excited for this season. It was a great start!

[Haley James Scott]

(Are you Serious? )

I just loved this Episode. I was so Glad they didn't put Nathan into a Coma or anything. He was alright mostly. I loved when they show the Flashback as to what Rachel said but i was a little Disappointed that they didn't show Haley Secret. Poor Brooke though. She just couldn't take it i guess after everything that has happened. Breaking up with Luke. and Lucas just sitting there and saying nothing and then when he did talk all he said was Sorry. What was up with that. I think there so going toward a Leyton Season for season 4. I was happy that Rachel got yelled at and of the person to Yell at her it was Haley i was so happy for that. Not only did Rachel Mess up Nathan mentally she Ruined what suppose of been the Best Day of Naley wedding plus Coop might die because of her Selfishness. It's good that Peyton is getting a Brother but one thing keeps bugging me. If that's her Brother Derek. first how did he get her I'm and how dose he know her. .... Questions and more Question. So i take it, It's Brooke that is pregnant or is it Haley. After all we never heard what the Conversation that Brooke and Haley had. Also the Doctor said yes your Pregnant she didn't say who. Yes we all think its Brooke but can it be Haley? ...I just loved this Episode so much. Poor Nathan his mental State is so not right... Haley had ever right Yelling at Rachel i would have actually had a few Choice words for Rachel myself. anyone would have done the same thing. Rachel is really Selfish thinking of no one else but herself. I really hope she gets Punished by the law too. I mean really alot of people get Rejected that doesn't mean they lie about a Pregnancy and Try to Drive a limo off a Bridge and kill everyone. including herself. I really love the Fighting between Rachel and Haley and i hope there more Scene like that. I would love to see Haley Character hate someone for a Chance. She always acts like everyone has a good side maybe Rachel is the one person that Haley well Truly hate now.

[Bethany Joy]

(yes, somehow there were two season 4 boards, one where it was supposed to be, and one as a subboard in 'One Tree Hill Talk'. I only created one, but somehow they were connected. So when I deleted the one that was a subboard, it deleted this one at the same time causing the thread to get deleted. It was really weird. But now I re-created this board and there isn't a duplicate anymore lol)

--------------------------------------

Yes I agree with everything you said. I definatly liked Haley getting mad for once! I mean, everyone deserves to be angry sometime, and when could she possibly be angrier? I mean, Rachel ruined her wedding, and then almost killed her husbend!

And then I am really curious about this whole thing with the IM coming in when Peyton and Lucas were hugging. Could it be Derek? But if it is... how did he get her screenname? It's just all really really weird.

And I am really confused about who is actually pregnant! Is it Brooke, or Haley? It really could be either. The reason I am leaning towards Brooke is because don't you think that Haley would have taken Nathan with her rather than Brooke? It would make sense for Brooke to take Haley though considering she just broke up with Lucas, and she is no longer friends with Peyton. So I'm thinking it's Brooke. But you never know!

[Haley James Scott]

Yea. I love that Haley has Grown so much, She only finds the nice in people and i think it's about time Haley feels some Hatted and the best person for that is Rachel. Like you said Rachel ruined Haley and Nathan wedding and not only that but she put Cooper in a Coma. She is a selfish Child and i see why that Cooper Broke up with her. Anyways. I hope there so more Drama between Hales and Rachel i would love to see that alot. We all know that Haley can fight for her man i would love to see just how far well she fight for him. All i know is that Haley not going to give up Nathan that easy.

Yea. It's Derek. I mean who else could it be. Someone told me it could be Lucas but how did they get that. There was only three time she has been on Two times "Watchinguwatchingme" Has been on line, Lucas has been in the room with Peyton. So it cant be Lucas. But if it is Derek. How did he get Peyton's Address and why wont he tell her anything beside Welcome and I'm watching you.

Yea, Join the Club. I don't know who it is anymore. When i first saw it i was like OK it's Brooke. Then watching that part again i was sure it was Haley and then i kept thinking about it and i didn't know it can be either of them. I'm just so confused on the whole thing. I know Brooke and Haley went together because Brooke broke up with Luke so it isn't like she could tell him. and Haley, She couldn't tell Nathan. I mean he went though Basically Hell and back. I think she just wanted to go with someone that was in there right mind right now. Also what did Brooke and Haley talk about before going to the Doctor i want to know about that Conversation.

[Bethany Joy]

Well hopefully we'll find out the answers to all of our questions next episode!

[onetreehilljunkie]

I had really liked it the espiode. I was really happy that Brooke had broke up with Lucas. Lucas did go to Peyton after Brooke had broke up with him.

[Gwen Catalano]

That is very cool and thank you for posting this and I am very sorry that your thread got deleted.

~Bethany Joy Galeotti

[samanthajessie]

i luvd the way this episode started with lucus n hayley in the hospital n then explaining it all in such intricate details.