Post by superjunior on Nov 2, 2009 3:23:07 GMT -5
This would be original, if I actually thought most of the results would stick. I give it 4 out of 6.Dollhouse Season 1 DVD Box set
The effects were very well done, with some new displays of power. I give it 6 out of 6.Smallville DVD Box Set
The story has events well worthy of a season finale.The L Word Seasons 1-6 DVD Boxset The end of Doomsday¡¯s arc is worth the buildup, next season¡¯s main villain is nicely revealed, and the relationship between Lois and the red-blue blur is effectively set up. The Office DVD Box setSadly, there¡¯s also an event that, if left unchanged, will infuriate many fans for deviations from canon, or, if changed, will infuriate many fans for the use of yet another reset button (with a likely reset button established prior to the event.) The King of Queens 1-9 DVD Box set They really wrote themselves into a no win situation. It¡¯s a better reset than Chloe waking up and telling a showering Patrick Duffy about her odd dream, but it¡¯s going to be really hard to use without upsetting someone. Friends DVD Box setIt also seemed like there was a reshoot on a major scene, as a line of dialogue in the following scene made it sound like Chloe hadn¡¯t seen two people she was just standing next to for some time. Ghost Whisperer DVD Box set I give it 4 out of 6.Smallville 1-8 DVD
The acting was well done all around, with the right reactions and tensions to keep it all going. Supernatural DVD Cassidy Freeman is shaping up very well as the villain who truly wants to be a hero, but simply doesn¡¯t know how.Battlestar Galactica 1-4 DVD The others played off each other very nicely, especially in the ¡°phonebooth¡± and ¡°new confidant¡± scenes. I give it 5 out of 6.Entourage Season 6 DVD Boxset
Doctor who DVD Box set The emotional response was excellent until it returned from the last commercial break. At that point, it felt like all bets were off, as nothing from then on would count. Naruto DVD Box Set This is the risk of prequels: some changes won¡¯t be kept if they¡¯re going to respect the source material, or they will be kept if they¡¯re willing to alienate some of the established fan base. I give it 3 out of 6.
The production was generally good. The scene that seems to have been reshot should have also involved a reshoot of the scene that followed, but otherwise, it all worked. I give it 4 out of 6.Gossip Girl DVD Box set
Overall, it was a generally good finale, but one bad writing decision just mars the complete package. I give it 3 out of 6.Grey's Anatomy Seasons 1-5 DVD Boxset
In total, Doomsday receives 29 out of 42.Smallville DVD Box Set
The effects were very well done, with some new displays of power. I give it 6 out of 6.Smallville DVD Box Set
The story has events well worthy of a season finale.The L Word Seasons 1-6 DVD Boxset The end of Doomsday¡¯s arc is worth the buildup, next season¡¯s main villain is nicely revealed, and the relationship between Lois and the red-blue blur is effectively set up. The Office DVD Box setSadly, there¡¯s also an event that, if left unchanged, will infuriate many fans for deviations from canon, or, if changed, will infuriate many fans for the use of yet another reset button (with a likely reset button established prior to the event.) The King of Queens 1-9 DVD Box set They really wrote themselves into a no win situation. It¡¯s a better reset than Chloe waking up and telling a showering Patrick Duffy about her odd dream, but it¡¯s going to be really hard to use without upsetting someone. Friends DVD Box setIt also seemed like there was a reshoot on a major scene, as a line of dialogue in the following scene made it sound like Chloe hadn¡¯t seen two people she was just standing next to for some time. Ghost Whisperer DVD Box set I give it 4 out of 6.Smallville 1-8 DVD
The acting was well done all around, with the right reactions and tensions to keep it all going. Supernatural DVD Cassidy Freeman is shaping up very well as the villain who truly wants to be a hero, but simply doesn¡¯t know how.Battlestar Galactica 1-4 DVD The others played off each other very nicely, especially in the ¡°phonebooth¡± and ¡°new confidant¡± scenes. I give it 5 out of 6.Entourage Season 6 DVD Boxset
Doctor who DVD Box set The emotional response was excellent until it returned from the last commercial break. At that point, it felt like all bets were off, as nothing from then on would count. Naruto DVD Box Set This is the risk of prequels: some changes won¡¯t be kept if they¡¯re going to respect the source material, or they will be kept if they¡¯re willing to alienate some of the established fan base. I give it 3 out of 6.
The production was generally good. The scene that seems to have been reshot should have also involved a reshoot of the scene that followed, but otherwise, it all worked. I give it 4 out of 6.Gossip Girl DVD Box set
Overall, it was a generally good finale, but one bad writing decision just mars the complete package. I give it 3 out of 6.Grey's Anatomy Seasons 1-5 DVD Boxset
In total, Doomsday receives 29 out of 42.Smallville DVD Box Set